NB. We've kept this page separate from our EMS/IR Metabolic Horse page as true Cushings/PPID has its own complex metabolic circumstances.
Image - EquiNatural's
Cookie, Cushing's diagnosed aged 14.
Imagine all the problems that could arise from just one bill getting lost in the mail. Your power or water could get turned off, or you might lose your wifi and be unable to work. It could even end up affecting your credit history. So many issues that might result from just one message not getting where it needed to go.
Now imagine that process happening inside your body. And imagine that for every message that wasn’t properly delivered, another gets thrown off course. Welcome to the world of hormone imbalance.
Living longer can bring about health issues that than we didn’t need to consider in the past, and although age isn't always a factor with Cushing's, the endocrine system - the home of all the glands that make hormones - and specifically the pituitary gland which runs the whole hormone show, is adversely affected as we all age, whether human or horse, and whether we like it or not.
If you're interested in the history, Cushing's Disease was named after Harvey Cushing, an eminent American neurosurgeon, who described the first (human) patients with Cushing's in 1912. in our equine world it's now also known (more appropriately) as PPID - Pituitary Pars Intermedia Dysfunction.
My own experience with equine Cushing's Disease first came out of the blue many years ago with my then very young step-daughter, Tabatha's, first pony, Dinky.
We'd not long had Dinks - just 6-weeks; he was a lovely senior chap, around 20yo, and perfect as a first lead-rein pony for Tabs. Yet very unexpectedly on his daily walk, he went from happily walking out the previous day to seriously lame in all four hooves alongside very worrying, very laboured breathing – all typical signs of acute laminitis. This literally happened overnight - the previous day he'd been fine; the next, he wasn't.
Although we instantly alleviated his symptoms, there had been other niggling signs on the sidelines - even though we were still getting to know him, we were approaching summer and it was obvious that his winter coat wasn't shifting. He was also noticeably drinking and weeing excessively and saturating his stable. We suspected Cushing's and got him tested. It came back positive.
... and Tabby's now third pony, Cookie (pictured above), also started presenting with the classic non-shedding curly coat, still holding onto it in August. Cookie was a hairy 13.2hh Gypsy cob with a polar-bear coat in winter, so trust me when I say her non-shedding curly coat was duvet-thick. She was also noticeably lethargic, plus she seemed so sad which was very out of character for her. She was just 14 at the time.
Dinks and Cookie were our two Cushing's ponies who we kept comfortable till their passing. We sadly lost Cookie in the autumn of 2022 when whe was 22yo. For the last couple of years of her life she'd started having seizures, and one day she went down and didn't get up, so we made the final call. We knew it had been coming, but it's still never easy. She was one in a million, one of the sweetest girls you could ever meet with a princess-pony mane you could bury your face in. She's back home now, in a shiny wooden casket under the TV, so we can still chat to her 😉.
These days? Every spring and autumn, and a lot in between, the number of Cushing's diagnoses increase disproportionately, as more of us are unsure whether our horse's coat is changing 'normally' or not. And then there's ′'pseudo-Cushing's', where some horses show the classic Cushing's presentation, but where it's not due to pituitary adenoma and more about disregulated adrenal glands that are releasing too much cortisol.
Worse still, youngstock as young as 2-years old are now being 'diagnosed' with Cushing's. Yes you read that right. 2-yo's. I mean ... how??? How are they presenting? I'm going to stick my neck out here and say they absolutely don't have Cushing's, but because a vet tests them and their bloods show a high ACTH blood test, they get the label firmly stamped on them and are put straight onto Prascend. Aged just 2. Which in my humble opinion is just bonkers, and more about the vets cashing in.
So, here's my take on it all, and a quick heads-up, alongside an equally quick disclaimer that the following (apart from where I've quoted sources) is all My Own Opinion, although obviously based on all my own research/studies/training/experience over the last 15+ years.
Personally I have a bit of an issue - well, a Big Issue - with the whole ACTH testing thing. Of course, due to the nature of what we do here at EquiNatural, all I hear are client stories of truly miserable side-effects courtesy of the eye-wateringly expensive drug, Prascend (the vets' conventional Cushing's drug of choice). What's worrying is that we're also seeing horses barely presenting with any associated symptoms, yet being immediately prescribed with Prascend for life, based simply on a higher-than-normal ACTH test, which we'll talk about a bit more as we go.
Now here's a thing. In humans, the ACTH test is one of five diagnostic methods that must all be positive in order to diagnose Cushing's, because it's said that the ACTH test alone is far too unreliable. Yet for our horses, the ACTH test is constantly offered and advertised as the 'gold standard' of diagnostics, and upon which all Cushing's diagnoses are made.
To repeat, Prascend is an eye-wateringly expensive vet med (so someone's making a ton of money off it - more on this below), and remember, it's prescribed for life - and all on the basis of a quick ACTH test, a hormone that is scientifically known to go up and down very naturally, depending on variable factors.
There's no welfare issue with a curly coat (hirsutism) - you can clip as and when required. There's also no evidence that Prascend reduces the lami risk - a Cushing's horse with lami is no different to a regular horse getting lami, and getting beloved Ned on Prascend doesn't mean he can now become a couch potato on lush grass and sugarlumps. Unless you're going to change how you do things, there is absolutely zero point in putting your Cushing's pony on Prascend.
Prascend can also have side effects. However, for the sake of balance, it should be emphasised that not all horses on Prascend have side effects. That said, around 30% of horses/ponies develop inappetence, lethargy and/or diarrhoea. And ... there's always the risk of false-positive ACTH results if you're testing in Autumn. One controlled study (Ed Knowles et al, 2018) shows that there's a 70% chance that if the result is incorrect, it will also show negative the following Spring. This study looked at 88 ponies, 56 of who tested positive in the Autumn. Of these 56, 39 then tested negative the following Spring, having received no treatment. That's a huge percentage who would otherwise, and unnecessarily, have been prescribed Prascend for life.
As more research comes out, critical thinking and advice moves on. Analyse, retest, discuss … We really shouldn't continue to do something simply because it’s how it's always been done. Which for the record is a statement a qualified vet once said to me, when I disagreed on something he said and questioned him. "That's how we've always done it," he replied. So there.
I have to ask, does a higher-than-normal ACTH test always mean an actual pituitary tumour? I mean, Cushing's is a Big Deal, as is the health of a Cushing's horse/pony's owner's bank account. Surely something as big a deal as a tumour in the brain should at the very least be confirmed with some kind of scan?
And surely (and especially if there are no clinical signs), doesn't it makes sense to wait then retest in Spring when the coat starts to change? Lots of 'positive' tested horses have perfectly normal ACTH levels when they're retested.
So to the real question - is it Cushing's, or not?
The endocrine - hormone - system is basically a network of glands and organs located throughout the body, with the pituitary gland being the Grand Master of all the glands because it tells the other glands what to do. They all work together to secrete hormones, aka neurotransmitters, which are chemical messengers that travel around the body in the blood, transmitting signals from the brain to control/regulate many of the body’s functions by stimulating specific cells or tissues into action.
Cushing's Disease/PPID results from a benign tumour on the pituitary gland which affects its function. Which means, if the pituitary's function's gone wonky, this disrupts the entire hormone signalling which then disrupts many of the body's functions. This has a profoundly disrupting effect on the body with many spin-off syndromes, i.e. the non-shedding of the coat and the eventual - and guaranteed - IR.
However, the biggest - yet probably least recognised or talked about - change comes from an excess production of the adrenal gland hormones, adrenalin and cortisol. Adrenalin, the survival hormone, prepares the body for 'fight/flight' so puts the body in a 'wired' state, while cortisol, the stress hormone, floods the bloodstream with acid and starts to shut down the energy-sapping systems in the body, i.e. digestion, so as to direct all the body's blood to the muscles so that the body can fight/fly. When these two hormones are permanently in control of the cockpit, the horse feels both tired and wired at the same time, which eventually leads to abject misery, exhaustion, and a state of ongoing chronic stress.
Alongside this is also the perfectly natural age-related drop in dopamine hormone, which in itself impacts pituitary function and the hypothalamic:pituitary:adrenal axis, which may also alter thyroid function.
ACTH (Adrenocorticotropic) hormone is secreted by the pituitary gland and has a variety of effects in the body, including ensuring that the adrenal glands are stimulated to produce (balanced levels of) cortisol.
Meanwhile, as horses age, and as with us humans, the levels of dopamine - the reward hormone (i.e. that bliss state we feel after eating chocolate) decrease naturally. As the older horse becomes susceptible to the loss of dopamine, the Pars intermedia (part of the pituitary gland) produce an excess of hormones including ACTH, so a higher ACTH test could simply mean you have an older horse who is naturally producing less dopamine. Hence why focusing on improving dopamine levels should perhaps be more about what we should be thinking about (more on this below).
Thing is though, testing ACTH levels in the blood is the recognised conventional veterinary standard for diagnosing Cushings, yet science now knows that a high ACTH value doesn't necessarily mean Cushing's/PPID, giving instead what's now known as a 'false positive' result. It's now known that the ACTH value fluctuates over the day, even in healthy horses, so testing via blood values only shows a snapshot at the exact moment when the blood is drawn (similar to vetting a prospective new horse - they're only as sound as they are on that particular day).
On the one hand, there are natural circadian fluctuations depending on the time of day, the circadian rhythm being the 24-hr cycle in the physiological process of all us living beings. On the other hand more ACTH is also released whenever the horse is under stress; we're talking anything as irrelevant as a herd squabble to more serious stressors such as hunger or chronic, ongoing pain. Equally, some horses stress as soon as they see the vet's car pull in. All examples which can record an increased ACTH value.
In a normal functioning body, when a certain level of ACTH is reached, cortisol feeds this information back to the pituitary gland which then reduces (balances) the release of ACTH. However, when there's a pituitary tumour, this feedback mechanism is disrupted. No matter how much cortisol relates the ACTH levels to the pituitary gland, the pituitary will keep releasing ACTH, so the Cushing's horse will have a permanently elevated ACTH level.
Cue a valid Cushing's/PPID diagnosis. Which means we now have depression, exhaustion, brain fog, anxiety and stress, on top of imminent insulin-resistance, because ...
As if managing all-things-PPID isn't a juggling act enough, cortisol also increases blood sugar levels and enhances the brain’s use of glucose.
Reminder - when the horse is anxious, signals are sent to the adrenal glands to release adrenalin and cortisol, which as we know triggers the fight/flight syndrome. As long as this fight/flight reaction in the body stays active, cortisol continues to release sugars into the bloodstream, and here comes the side effects of high cortisol levels.
We're looking at abnormal glucose metabolism leading to weight gain, typically cresty necks, rear/belly fat pads, and ... insulin resistance (IR) - all the precursors to metabolic laminitis. It’s a vicious cycle - as cortisol levels increase, so insulin levels must then increase to try and keep glucose within what the body thinks are ‘normal’ levels. In humans, we call chronic, unregulated levels of insulin Type 2 Diabetes.
Getting the PPID/IR controlled and managed is essential in order to minimise the associated laminitis risk, so focusing on reducing stressors and keeping anxiety at bay will help control the cortisol levels.
Meanwhile, the natural circadium rhythm is busy determining sleeping/feeding patterns, brainwave activity, hormone production, cell regeneration and other biological activities. Come autumn and with the daylight hours becoming shorter and a drop in temperatures, it's normal for ACTH levels to increase when the body’s natural hormone levels tell the winter coat to start growing. So for a PPID-diagnosed horse we're now getting higher cortisol levels on top of already-high cortisol levels.
What is absolute cast-iron knowledge with PPID is that the endocrine system needs stabilising with hormonal - and adrenal - support. Then when the IR kicks in, there's the absolute need to manage the IR/blood glucose levels, and the ever-present lami risk. Some of the symptoms of both PPID and IR will overlap despite the two being kind of mutually exclusive, but as Dr Eleanor Kellon (head of the ECIR group) says, “Every Cushing's horse will get IR.”
As if PPID wasn’t challenging enough with the stress and lami risk, PPID and IR can also lead to immune system overreactions like allergies, weight gain/weight loss, runny eyes, swollen sheaths/udders, excessive drinking/peeing, muscle loss, depressed immune system, and slow wound healing.
So what the heck do we do?
Convention these days says that PPID should be managed with one particular drug, Prascend, this being the gold standard drug of choice (Prascend is the brand name of the active ingredient Pergolide), and the IR managed with diet as per the typical metabolic/EMS protocol (see our Metabolic Horse page.
However, the renowned ECIR group run by Dr Kellon (reminder, Dr Kellon is a vet) takes a slightly different stance, in that: "Prascend should be the first line treatment for obviously advanced and/or laminitic horses with PPID. If it's an early case, feeding Agnus castus is a reasonable first step as long as the owner and veterinarian realise it may lose effectiveness."
However ...
Dr Christina Fritz is a Biologist with a PhD in Animal Physiology/Neurobiology, and has been treating horses since 2006, focusing on metabolic therapy using holistic feeding methods via healthy, natural horse nutrition. She publishes in German, but with the help of Google Translate, here are some salient points from a valuable study she carried out on Prascend (sadly the page link to her study doesn't seem to work, but here's the link all the same in case it comes back: - https://wissen.sanoanimal.de/2021/02/03/wie-wirkt-prascent/?fbclid=IwAR2dGnRpDRhUelCrkDPhyoX8xcnNXNXCEWkSg_G8iksDRiJw3GP6fwXj_pM
Quote:
End quote.
And so to where there's another way. With it being known that plant extracts have less side effects, natural therapy may well be safer for long term use.
First up, there's no doubt that the berries from the revered Vitex agnus-castus tree are renowned for helping Cushings/PPID horses, with many peer-reviewed studies showing as such. Used for its gentle, tonic action on the anterior pituitary's action in adrenal hormone regulation, agnus-castus is an amphoteric herb, meaning it may help maintain normal hormonal levels, rather than cause them to go up or down.
NB - while it can certainly help with the visible presentations, it won't necessarily control the ACTH levels. (Not wishing to fly in the face of science, personally we had remarkable success with both Dinks and Cookie, alongside the amino acid Tyrosine).
However, Dr Kellon posts against feeding agnus castus berry alongside Prascend: https://drkhorsesense.wordpress.com/2021/05/18/mixing-chastetree-berries-with-pergolide-in-cushings-horses/.
Then there's Mucuna pruriens, with the rather catchy common name of Kapikacchu, which has natural sources of L-DOPA to enhance circulating dopamine levels similar to medications, but offers added benefits of supporting nerve, brain, and pituitary axis functioning to target nerve function through antioxidant and anti-inflammatory support.
However, again, as with agnus castus, it's not recommended to feed Mucuna if your horse is on Prascend, as it could result in an over-production of dopamine, possibly resulting in side effects. Hence why we have two CushTonic blends to support the PPID horse - CushTonic Mk.1 for horses not on Prascend, and CushTonic Mk.2 for horses on Prascend, which excludes the agnus-castus and mucuna.
What I can also absolutely guarantee you is that the right nutrition also goes a huge way to help. PPID is a degenerative condition that requires whole-body nutrition for health and wellness - see our Feeding our Horses/Why what we feed has to be right page.
Sadly we know there's no cure for PPID, but the good news is that once it's been diagnosed, management is fairly straightforward and can help a horse return to a comfortable lifestyle.
Our Cookie recently had a worrying seizure episode which I suspected was related to her Cushings. After doing the usual googling, I found the following related notes courtesy of The Chronicle of the Horse forum (which sadly no longer seems to be around as the link no longer works).
I should add that the forum post dates back to 2006 so in theory it’s outdated; however, here in 2019 I still found the following info useful. Credit due to poster Melyni (PhD) PAS, Dipl. ACAN, answering a question from poster ‘equineelders’, of Travellers Rest Equine Elders Sanctuary, whose horse had presented with seizures similar to our Cookie:
“At AAEP in early Dec I attended a couple of talks on Cushings. The current thinking was that it isn't tumour per se of the anterior pituatary but a loss of the dopaminergic neurons that descend from the hypothalmus into the pars intermediar.
If I understand it correctly these neurons have an inhibitory effect on the cells of the pars intermedia, and thus the loss of the neurons means a loss of the inhibition, thus the pars intermediar cells begin to put out more and more hormones esp ACTH plus others, which leads to a secondary hypocorticoidism.
It's thus more similar to Parkinson's than to a tumour. Patients with Parkinsons suffer from neurolgical symptoms, such as muscle rigidity, spasms and loss of balance. Loss of control of fine motor neurons occurs as well.
So if you think about Parkinsons as the underlying cause (loss of dopaminergic neurons) rather than a cancerous growth, the symptoms make more sense. Not that this helps anyone dealing with a seizuring horse.
There is a theoretical way to modify the intake on amino-acids to enhance the dopaminergic pathways as opposed to the seratonergic, eg don't feed tryptophan; supplements that contain the amino-acids threonine and tyrosine are effective, but this is not scientific only anecdotal.
Seratonin is made from different precursors than dopamine. They are both made from amino-acid precursors but not the same ones, and there is some indication that increasing the seratonin in Parkinsons’ patients exacerbates the symptoms, as the pathway may be competitive.
Dopamine comes from Tyrosine and Threonine, while Seratonin comes from Tryptophan via the 5HT pathway. Arginine may also be involved in the dopamine pathway.
How do chromium and magnesium fit into this? We have a few on supplements per vet's recommendation, but I don't know specifically what they are doing. From what I have read in such literature as exists, the Mg helps with the peripheral circulation, as in it keeps the small arterioles open and maintains the circulation to the extremities (all data from human studies) thus it (may) minimise the loss of blood flow to the feet, and the subsequent laminitis. It also seems (in humans) to have an anti-inflammatory effect, as in, it reduces C reactive proteins from the adipose tissue.
Chromium is part of the enzyme system that picks up the glucose from the blood stream and enters it into the cell. Thus the extra chromium helps to clear the bloodstream of the glucose, and the extra magnesium helps to maintain peripheral circulation.
All this information came from human studies, and thus you cannot be too literal in saying that this is what happens in horses, as these things don't always transfer from species to species, but as there is next to no research in horses, that is all we have. I do know from what work I have done, that giving the Cr and Mg to pre-Cushings and Cushings horses you get better laminar bloodflow and a reduction in the symptoms, such that the pergolide dosage can be reduced.
We have measured the reduction in neck thickness and in the abnormal fat pockets, and we can show an improved circulation to the foot. But these effects aren't treating the underlying cause.
Giving essential amino-acids to these horses reduces the loss of muscle tissue and the muscle wasting. Again this is treating the symptoms, not the cause, but overall the horses look and feel better, and are more active, which in itself improves their metabolism.”
As a result of this information, I'm now adding L-Tyrosine into Cookie's feedbowl.
A recent 'Dr K's Horse Sense' post shows that onset pain may also affect ACTH testing, as it's known that both ACTH and cortisol levels are more likely to be higher than normal ranges in acute illness.
A 2020 German study looked at hospitalised horses in pain from various sources including colic, laminitis and orthopedic presentations, and with no clinical signs of PPID. The study found that "... acute pain resulted in markedly elevated cortisol and insulin resistance."
Since acute stress, wounds etc., can cause the adrenal glands to release cortisol without ACTH increase, it’s unclear from that study if acute pain will influence ACTH, although it certainly increases insulin. The thinking is that testing for both ACTH and insulin levels should be avoided in the first 24-hrs after onset of pain.
See the full article here: https://drkhorsesense.wordpress.com/2021/06/08/insulin-acth-and-pain/
That's it for now. Meanwhile, click on the SHOP link below to see our supporting Cushing's/PPID product range.
Any information contained within
is not intended to replace veterinary or other professional advice.
*
Trading Standards EC Feed
Hygiene Regulation (183/2005), Registration No. GB280/4203
*
HACCP certified facility (an intern-
ational standard that ensures we meet
food safety standards)
*
Registered in England. Company
Number 11075894, Reg'd Office: Unit 4 Rookery Farm, Radstock BA3 4UL
* VAT No. GB 310214964